News, Politics and Opinion covering Kyrgyzstan and Central Asia.
Friday, August 12, 2011
Kyrgyz Release More Water to Fight Kazakh Drought
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Rate of Exchange: The Costs of Democratic Transition in Kyrgyzstan, and Who Picks up the Bill
the Central Election Commission of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan announced on July 14 that it estimates a cost of 449 Million Kyrgyz Som (KGS) to conduct the upcoming Presidential Elections. The election marks the first change of the top executive since Roza Otunbayeva was selected as Interim/Transitional President in a package vote along with adopting the new Constitution that expressly limits the powers of the President in July 2010.
Thursday, July 14, 2011
Indefinite Deployment: US Neocons Explain Rationale of Never Leaving Kyrgyz Airbase

originally posted on CA-NEWS.org
by Ryan Weber
The US will continue to have a military presence in Kyrgyzstan, perhaps indefinitely, despite plans for a complete withdrawal from Afghanistan by 2014, according to a veteran conservative analyst and former Defense Department staff.
The admission was made on July 6 at an event hosted by the Hudson Institute, a neoconservative Washington, D.C. think tank with a history of promoting US national security interests.
The comments, by Seth Cropsey (pictured), a Senior Fellow at Hudson, and formerly of the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute, came in response to an audience question about the future of US-Kyrgyz relations after the end of military operations in Afghanistan, and the presumed closure of the US airbase at Bishkek's Manas International airport. The base, which opened in December 2001 and is now known as the Transit Center at Manas (or Manas TC), has been a lightning rod of controversy since 2005, and more recently figured as an international negotiating chip for then-President Kurmanbek Bakiev to elicit a a six-fold increase in the American's lease, up to $60 million per year in 2009.
US Military and diplomatic envoys have long argued that Manas TC is critical to the Afghan war effort, largely over-shadowing other topics of US-Kyrgyz foreign relations such as economic development, anti-corruption, and Human Rights violations under the current and past administrations.
But according to Cropsey, who is a former Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and Low-Intensity Combat, future geopolitical concerns will necessitate a US presence long after the last US troops leave Afghanistan. He specifically cited a nuclear Iran, prolonged Afghan in-fighting, or an aggressive China all as viable justifications for a permanent US presence.
Saturday, June 11, 2011
Going Post-al: US-Central Asia Policy Post-bin Laden
Friday, May 27, 2011
The Best We Can: Kyrgyz Government Panel Explains Circumstances, Handling of June 2010 Osh Violence
Monday, May 23, 2011
Clouded Transparency: Kyrgyz Government Responds to KIC Report on June 2010 Osh Violence
Sunday, April 10, 2011
Taken Aback: International Commission on June 2010 Osh Violence Issues Stunning Report
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
Historian Alexander Knyazev on Current Events in Kyrgyzstan, their Historical Roots, and Likely Outcomes
Reposted from Gazeta.kg, originally published on Polit.kg.
Interview by Hilarion Zvyagintsev
Translation by Google/style edit by Ryan Weber
As part of the "Sharp Corners" series which focuses on the portrayal of Kyrgyz history in school textbooks, Polit.kg interviewed prominent historian Alexander Knyazev, Ph.D [of the Kyrgyz Slavic University, Bishkek]. The conversation quickly moved past the works of Osmonov and other pseudo-historians, and ultimately dealt with the connection of the past, present, and prospects for the future state of Kyrgyzstan.
Hilarion Zvyagintsev: In your opinion, what role does the Kyrgyz ethnic group play in the history of Kyrgyzstan? Why has this subject become such a fixture in today's debates?
Alexander Knyazev:- Ethnocentricity in the interpretation and teaching of history is largely the result of compromise among the unprincipled parts of the scientific community. At the turn of the 1980s and 90s, when the idea of ethnocentrism began to dominate - how this dishonored the academic community of the [Kyrgyz] Republic will be discussed - many just began to go along [with this narrative]. This is particularly noticeable in the proclamation of the 2,200th anniversary of Kyrgyz statehood, the 3,000th anniversary of Osh, and the question of the historicity of Manas as a person. It is characterized by lack of professionalism among our scientists. No profession can exist without lapses in professional ethics, but it's wrong to change [the way we write] history in favor of short-term interests. This causes harm and does not bring any benefit, and in a multicultural society - even more so. In a context where the socio-economic situation does not allow most people to travel outside the republic, not only young people, a huge part of society formed a provincial consciousness, ideology, limited to the extent of Kyrgyzstan and the myths operating here.
Wednesday, December 29, 2010
Post-Vote, Declined Mandates Reshaped Kyrgyzstan’s Legislature
Tuesday, December 28, 2010
No Thank You: Many Respublika Candidates Refused Mandates
- Babanov, Omurbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#1
- Alimbekov, Nurbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#2
- Pirmatov, Ishaq - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#3
- Sultanbekova, Cholpon - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#4
- Isaev, Kanatbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#5
- Torobaev, Bakyt - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#6
- Sulaimanov, Altynbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#7
- Zavgorodnyaya, Alevtina - Russian - DECLINED
- Moldobaev, Askhat - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Baatyrbekov, Almazbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#8
- Esenamanov, Zamirbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Aknazarova, Rosa - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#9
- Boko, Kenjebek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#10
- Aripov, Nazarali - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#11
- Turuskulov, Jyrgalbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Djumaliev, Elmira - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#12
- Obdunov, Elmurat - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#13
- Kadyrkulov, Iskender - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Osmonov, Malik - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#14
- Amanbaeva, Urulkan - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#15
- Arym, Kubat - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Aitmatov, Kushtarbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#16
- Shaynazarov, Tynchtyk - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#17
- Omurbekova, Altynai - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#18
- Andash, Turatbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Ismailov, Ulanbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Nizovskii, Yuri - Russian - DECLINED
- Shayymkulova, Ainura - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Jolbolduev, Pamirbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Bakirov, Mirlan - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#19
- Oskonbaev, Beyshenbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Alimzhanova, Damir - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Asylbek, uulu Damirbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Duyshenbiev, Nursultan - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Murashev, Nurbek - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#20
- Dzhumabekova, Akylsayra - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Bekmatov, Abdyjapar - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#21
- Zakirov, Asylbek - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Sabirov, Maksat - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#22
- Sagynbaeva, Gulifa - Kyrgyz - DECLINED
- Rezhavaliev, Abdulatipov - Kyrgyz - Accepted, MP#23
What Mystery? US Probe reveals Bribery, Corruption, Incompetence... and No Ethics Violations?
Thursday, December 23, 2010
Skin & Bones: The Structure of the new Kyrgyz Parliament

by Ryan Weber
"It's fun to write about an ACTUAL Kyrgyz government instead of a hypothetical one."
-Jax Jacobsen, reporter for Central Asia Newswire, in a tweet on December 20th, 2010
With the December 17 announcement of a successful majority coalition agreement, the Kyrgyz Jogorku Kenesh parliament can finally get to the business of governing the Republic after more than 2 months of political stalemate. Following the results of the October 10 elections, 5 parties entered the 120-seat parliament, all far short of the 60 seats necessary to appoint a Prime Minister and other top positions. Ata-Jurt, the largest party, controlled just 28 seats, while Ata-Meken was the smallest with 18.
In rapid succession, the new coalition was able to fulfill its mandate by electing the new government's top leadership. Almazbek Atambaev of SDPK becomes Prime Minister (92 votes), Omurbek Babanov of Respublika becomes Deputy Prime Minister (88 votes), and Akhmat Khelidbekov of Ata-Jurt becomes Speaker of Parliament (101 votes).
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
Putting on a Show: Friends, Enemies & 'Frenemies' in Kyrgyz Politics
written by Asel Otorbayeva
style edit by Ryan Weber
Once again, Kyrgyz politicians place the importance of assigning government positions over actual governing.
Old Political Enemies
In its second attempt, the Kyrgyz parliament finally succeeded in electing a speaker. Their choice was the leader of the party [Ata-Jurt] which previously called for the return of ousted President Bakiev [actually, a rumor], and is comprised of many former allies to the fallen President.
Opponents [of Ata-Jurt] were highly critical of its intentions in the run-up to Parliamentary elections in October, charging it with a variety of "sins." Some even suggested members of Ata-Jurt helped instigate the June riots in Osh the ignited ethnic tension [and in several ways increased Ata-Jurts Nationalist rhetoric going into the election]. But the accusations against Ata-Jurt were never proven, and the other parties dropped attempts to link Ata-Jurt with the violence. Being veteran politicians, rather than defend themselves, Ata-Jurt enlisted [Kyrgyz] victims of the June events to protect their reputation.
Relatives of those killed during the April coup that removed Bakiev responded passionately to the former Bakiev administrators, [throwing eggs and] attempting to block their admittance to the new parliament. They demanded that such politicians never participate in government again, but the other ["pro-government"] parties did nothing to block their participation [such as passing a controversial Lustration law]. After a while, the general public acquiesced. [Respublika] party - as if it had forgotten the public distaste for Ata-Jurt - instructed the Social Democrat party (SDPK) to "make friends" with Ata-Jurt. They explained that economic concerns must trump personal animosity.
Now Almazbek Atambayev, SDPK leader and [recently-elected] Prime Minister must find a way to work with Akhmatbek Kelidbekov - the new Speaker of Parliament from Ata-Jurt. Whether they want to or not, their cooperation is vital for any progress [in Kyrgyzstan].
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
Who Will Become Author of Kyrgyz Political Default?
written by Asel Otorbayeva
style edit by Ryan Weber
In the throes of giving birth to a parliamentary majority coalition, Kyrgyzstan may suffer a second miscarriage. The reason is obvious - excessive greed [by party leaders] for key positions in the future parliament.
Which Prime Minister is Best?
The main battle area among the five parties appears to be for the top spot [in the restructured Kyrgyz] government. Leaders of Social Democratic Party of Kyrgyzstan (SDPK) and Ar-Namys party both want to become Prime Minister. For better or worse, neither are strangers to the political arena - each possessing ample experience as well as political baggage. And neither leader, Almazbek Atambayev of SDPK or Felix Kulov of Ar-Namys, show any sign of willingly stepping aside.
The Respublika party was chosen for the second mandate to form a majority coalition, and its leader, Omurbek Babanov, now faces one of the most difficult challenges of his career. Much younger than the other party leaders, and with less time in politics, he is finding it difficult to compete. His most persuasive arguments are unable to overcome the [entrenched] SDPK or the "iron shield" of Ar-Namys. It is no secret that ambitions for the Prime Minister position are entwined with hopes for the 2011 Presidential election. SDPK and Ar-Namys both aspire to the presidency, and controlling the Prime Minister may be a necessary 'trump card' for that effort.
Speaker’s Throne as Alternative
[Realizing that the new Kyrgyz Constitution dramatically increases the power of parliament, the position of Speaker of Parliament has become much more valuable. Now, not only the leader of the Ata-Meken party, [Omurbek Tekebaev] aspires to the post [he once held], but also members of Respublika, Ar-Namys, and Ata-Zhurt's co-chairman, Akhmatbek Kelidbekov.
Monday, December 13, 2010
Waiting for Parliament and a Kyrgyz Santa Claus

Tuesday, December 7, 2010
Panel Suggests Media, Representation, Corruption all Obstacles to Peace & Democracy in Kyrgyzstan
On the evening of December 6, the Elliott School at George Washington University in Washington, DC hosted a panel discussion titled, "Post-election Developments in Kyrgyzstan: The Tension Between Democracy Promotion and Conflict Mitigation."
The event was moderated by Dr. Sean Roberts, director of the International Development Studies Program at George Washington University, and author of the Roberts Report on Central Asia and Kazakhstan. Panelists included Alisha Khamidov, lecturer at the School of Advanced International Studies at the Johns Hopkins University; Jeff Goldstein, senior policy analyst of Eurasia at the Open Society Institute; and Sam Patten, senior program manager of Eurasia at Freedom House.
The event drew a respectable crowd of students and DC-based Eurasia analysts, and focused on the relationship between democracy promotion and (ethnic) conflict resolution in post-Bakiev Kyrgyzstan. Especially at issue was the tension between ethnic Kyrgyz and ethnic Uzbeks in the country's Southern regions and how certain political factions used nationalist rhetoric to exploit and encourage this tension for their own gain leading up to the October 10 parliamentary election.
Each offered their perspective on the nature of the widespread June violence that shook Osh and lead to the death of hundreds and the flight of tens of thousands of ethnic Uzbeks to the nearby border with Uzbekistan. Each speaker had been to Kyrgyzstan within the past 6 months, during the Osh violence, October elections, or both.
Monday, December 6, 2010
If at First you Don't Succeed: Kyrgyz Parliament Takes Another Shot at Forming Majority Coalition
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
Cutting the Deck: Expert Opinions Divided on Prospects for New Coalition in Kyrgyz Parliament
"The country is on the verge of economic and political collapse, and the ruling coalition will need team spirit. They won’t be able to cooperate without it. If we consider that each of the leaders will get their previous positions – Omurbek Tekebayev will become a Speaker, Almazbek Atambayev - Prime Minister and Omurbek Babanov - Deputy Prime Minister. In addition, recent incidents – arrest of an extremist group in the city of Osh and the explosion in the capital - had a sobering effect on the party leaders. All the incidents that broke out in the country after the April events and last outbreaks – the awareness that the state could collapse overnight and they will lose everything - joined the former oppositionists. The coalition, which could not be formed for a long time, had been established overnight. This means the coalition has a potential and contradictions between them have been minimized."
“It turns out that interests of the south won’t be taken into account in the parliament [because the three parties in the coalition are all seen as Northerners]. I think it were more challenging to create the coalition with participation of two northern and one southern party – Ata-Zhurt. Yes, many understand these parties are ideologic and political rivals but the level of the compromise would be higher… Such coalition would be more stable. Unfortunately, the artificial regionalism intensified after [the] April events. This is dangerous. I think politicians must follow regional balance when they will distribute the portfolios."